Super Lawyers Rising Stars
Top 100 Settlements, Motor Vehicle Accidents - 2019
America's Top 100 Attorneys
Million Dollar Advocates Forum
Miami Dade, Trial Lawyers Association
American Association for Justice

Does Who Got The Ticket Matter in a Florida Car Accident Case?

Flanagan & Bodenheimer Injury and Wrongful Death Law Firm

Amidst the chaos of a car accident, receiving a ticket can add another layer of stress to an already overwhelming situation. But does it really matter who got the ticket after your car accident in Florida? 

In Florida, the traffic crash report and any accompanying tickets are not automatically admissible as evidence in a personal injury car accident case. This may come as a surprise to many, as people often assume that official documentation from law enforcement carries significant weight in legal proceedings. However, in the context of a personal injury case resulting from a car accident, these documents do not automatically determine liability. 

So, if you’ve been given a ticket or citation for a car accident that was not your fault, you may wonder if you still have the right to file a claim. The answer is yes. Despite being issued a ticket, you are not excluded from seeking compensation for your injuries and damages.

Can Traffic Tickets Be Used As Evidence in Car Accident Cases?

The key to understanding the relevance of the ticket lies in its admissibility as evidence. If the police officer who issued the ticket witnessed the accident firsthand, their testimony regarding what they saw is admissible in court. In this scenario, their account of the events leading up to the accident could potentially influence the outcome of your case.

However, if the police officer arrived at the scene after the accident occurred and based their decision to issue a ticket solely on statements from those involved, the ticket holds little weight in a personal injury case. In these instances, the ticket is not admissible as evidence, and the officer cannot testify about their opinions regarding fault.

This distinction is crucial for accident victims to understand. Just because you received a ticket does not mean you are automatically at fault, nor does it impact your ability to seek compensation for your injuries. 

What Happens If I Pay The Fine on The Ticket?

When someone receives a ticket following a car accident in Florida, their response to it can have serious implications. If they opt to plead guilty and pay the fine without contesting the citation or consulting an attorney, this guilty plea can be utilized as evidence in court. Depending on the circumstances of the crash and the nature of the citation, this admission of guilt may play a role in determining fault for the car crash.

Insurance companies conduct thorough investigations into car accidents, seeking any evidence that can help reduce the compensation owed to victims. A guilty plea to a citation can serve as ammunition for insurers to undermine your claim and potentially dismiss it or offer minimal compensation.

A ticket alone may not necessarily impact the outcome of your personal injury case, whether it proceeds to litigation or settles outside of court. However, a guilty plea to a citation can certainly influence how your case unfolds and your ability to secure fair compensation for your injuries and damages.

If you were injured in a car crash in South Florida and you received a ticket from the police officer, you should still contact a Miami car accident attorney to determine the best course of action. Call Flanagan & Bodenheimer at 305-638-4143 for a free consultation in English or Spanish. 

How is Liability Determined in Florida Car Accident Cases?

In personal injury cases, fault in a car accident is determined through thorough investigation, examination of evidence, and expert testimony rather than solely relying on the issuance of a ticket. Liability depends on many factors, including:

  • Negligence: In many car accident cases, liability hinges on proving negligence. Negligence occurs when a person fails to exercise reasonable care, resulting in harm to others.
  • Traffic Laws: Florida’s traffic laws play a significant role in determining liability. Violations such as speeding, running red lights, and failure to yield are clear indicators of negligence and can help establish fault in a car accident case.
  • Comparative Negligence: Florida operates under a modified comparative negligence system. If an accident victim is deemed more than 50% responsible for their own damages, they cannot recover any compensation from other involved parties. The amount of compensation a plaintiff receives is directly reduced by the percentage of fault assigned to them.
  • Eyewitness Testimony & Expert Analysis: Eyewitness testimony from individuals who witnessed the accident can provide valuable insight into what transpired. Additionally, expert analysis, such as accident reconstruction specialists and medical professionals, can offer expert opinions regarding the cause of the accident and the extent of injuries suffered.
  • Documentation & Evidence: Building a strong case requires thorough documentation and evidence gathering. This may include photographs of the accident scene, damage to vehicles, medical records, and any other relevant documentation. The more evidence you have to support your claim, the stronger your case for establishing liability.

Free Consultation With a Miami Car Accident Attorney

When navigating the aftermath of a car accident in Florida, it’s essential to seek guidance from experienced personal injury lawyers who can help you understand your rights and options. At Flanagan & Bodenheimer, we understand the challenges that come with proving liability in Florida car accident cases. Our team of dedicated Miami car accident lawyers is committed to providing personalized legal representation tailored to your unique needs. We will work tirelessly to gather evidence, build a compelling case, and fight for the compensation you deserve.

Flanagan & Bodenheimer focuses exclusively on personal injury and wrongful death cases throughout Florida. While our main offices are located in Miami, FL and Hollywood, FL we accept cases throughout all of Florida including Fort Lauderdale, Kendall, Hialeah, Homestead, Aventura, West Palm Beach, Orlando, Tampa, Jacksonville, and other areas.

If you’ve been injured in a car accident in Miami, don’t hesitate to contact us at 305-638-4143 for a free consultation. Let us handle the legal complexities so that you can focus on your recovery.

Client Reviews

When faced with the repercussions of a personal injury, choosing the right lawyer for the work ahead is absolutely imperative. When this daunting task fell upon me following a motor vehicle accident, obtaining attorney...

Josh N.

Thank you all for your efforts, often in today's world, it seems everything is about money and people don't seem to care about others. I felt that this was not the case with you and I felt always that you had my best...


Michael Flanagan and his team were so supportive while handling my case. What I appreciated the most about working with Michael was his honesty and his no nonsense approach at getting the very best for his clients. I'm...

Talia M.
Daily Business Review
Houston Chronicle
Law 360
Number 1 Jury Verdict - Florida 2018
Top 100 Settlements, Motor Vehicle Accidents - 2019

When It Counts

Fill out the contact form or call us at 305-638-4143 to schedule your free consultation.

Free Case Review Schedule Your Appointment Today