NTSB Investigating Small Plane Crash in Ten Thousand Islands Near Everglades City

Federal investigators are examining a small plane crash that occurred Sunday in the Ten Thousand Islands region west of Everglades City after an aircraft overturned in the water with two people on board.

According to the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), the crash involved a 1981 Cessna A185F aircraft that went down under unknown circumstances and remains partially submerged.

The Collier County Sheriff’s Office confirmed that deputies, along with fire rescue and EMS crews, responded to reports of a plane in the water near the Port of the Islands resort, located between Marco Island and Everglades City.

Authorities initially received reports of an aircraft in the water rather than a confirmed crash. The aircraft, tail number N7574N, is registered to Black Dog Holding, Inc. in Pleasant Valley, New York.

Investigators confirmed:

• Two people were on board — a pilot and a passenger
• The plane overturned and became partially submerged
• Emergency crews searched the area to ensure no additional victims were in the water
• The conditions of those on board have not been publicly released

Witnesses in the area reported hearing rescue helicopters and seeing emergency vehicles rush to the scene as responders began search and rescue operations.

The NTSB has launched a full investigation into the crash and has sent an investigator to the scene. Once the aircraft is recovered from the water, investigators will:

• Document the crash site
• Examine the aircraft structure and systems
• Review maintenance and ownership records
• Analyze flight tracking data
• Evaluate weather and water conditions
• Examine pilot qualifications and recent flight activity

Flight tracking data reportedly showed the aircraft’s speed dropping rapidly from approximately 80 mph to zero, suggesting a sudden descent before impact.

However, officials emphasize that it is too early to determine the cause of the crash.

Potential Factors in Small Aircraft and Seaplane Crashes

Aircraft like the Cessna A185F, commonly known as a “Skywagon,” are designed to land on both runways and water when equipped with floats. Despite their durability and versatility, accidents can occur due to:

• Mechanical or engine issues
• Sudden weather changes
• Poor visibility
• Water or landing surface conditions
• Pilot decision-making or fatigue
• Navigation or equipment failures

Because this crash occurred in a remote island chain surrounded by water, environmental factors may play a significant role in the investigation.

How the NTSB Investigates Aviation Accidents

NTSB investigations focus on three primary areas:

1. The pilot – training, licensing, health, and recent activity
2. The aircraft – maintenance, mechanical condition, and safety systems
3. The operating environment – weather, visibility, and flight conditions

Investigators will also collect:

• Air traffic control communications
• Electronic flight data
• Witness statements
• Surveillance or video footage
• Information from electronic devices

The NTSB does not speculate about the cause of crashes during the early stages of an investigation. A final report may take months to complete.

Legal Considerations After Aviation Accidents

When aircraft crashes result in serious injuries or fatalities, determining liability can be complex. Potential legal claims may involve:

• Aircraft mechanical or manufacturing defects
• Maintenance or inspection failures
• Pilot negligence or operator error
• Charter or commercial operator liability
• Premises or operational hazards

Aviation accidents often require extensive investigation, expert analysis, and preservation of evidence to determine what went wrong and who may be responsible.

Representation for Aviation Accident Victims and Families

At Flanagan & Bodenheimer Injury & Wrongful Death Law Firm, we represent individuals and families affected by catastrophic accidents throughout Florida, including aviation incidents.

Our firm intentionally limits its caseload so clients receive direct access to experienced attorneys and personalized representation. We are prepared to investigate complex liability cases and pursue full compensation where negligence contributed to an accident.

We can assist by:

• Conducting independent investigations
• Working with aviation and crash reconstruction experts
• Identifying responsible parties and insurance coverage
• Handling all communications with insurers
• Pursuing maximum compensation under Florida law

There are no upfront costs, and we only get paid if we recover compensation for you.

If you or a loved one were injured in an aviation accident anywhere in Florida, contact Flanagan & Bodenheimer for a free and confidential consultation.